Senators Warn GENIUS Act Rules May Push Stablecoin Firms to Federal Oversight
Summary: Six bipartisan US senators urge the Treasury to extend safe harbor protections to state-supervised stablecoin issuers, warning that current GENIUS Act implementation rules could inadvertently steer firms toward federal licenses.
Six bipartisan senators on Tuesday urged the US Treasury Department to extend proposed regulatory protections to state-supervised stablecoin issuers, warning that current implementation rules for the GENIUS Act could steer firms toward federal licenses. In a letter addressed to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, the lawmakers argued that the existing proposal creates an uneven playing field that undermines the dual banking system intended by the legislation.
The signatories to the letter include Senators Cynthia Lummis and Kirsten Gillibrand, along with Angela Alsobrooks, Kevin Cramer, Pete Ricketts, and Mark Warner. They stated that the Treasury’s current proposal offers a safe harbor to certain issuers with pending federal applications and regulator-approved waivers, but provides no equivalent protection for issuers operating under state supervision. The senators warned that this disparity means issuers “may be incentivized to seek greater operational clarity under a federal license,” including through the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC). They emphasized that such an outcome was “the opposite of our intent in drafting this legislation.”
To address this uncertainty, the senators urged the Treasury to extend the safe harbor provisions to issuers in states that are expected to have qualifying regulatory frameworks in place before Jan. 18, 2028. This extension would reduce regulatory ambiguity while state certification reviews are pending. The GENIUS Act generally allows issuers with $10 billion or less in outstanding stablecoins to operate under qualifying state supervision, with exemptions available for those exceeding that threshold.
This latest request follows a June appeal in which a similar bipartisan group urged the Treasury to preserve state participation and clarify the certification process. At that time, the lawmakers argued that the Treasury’s initial proposal did not adequately address the timeline and procedural requirements related to state certification, creating uncertainty that could effectively bar future certifications if interpreted as a one-time window.
Industry participants have noted that the structural limits of state supervision may still drive firms toward federal charters regardless of safe harbor extensions. Kevin Wysocki, head of policy at Anchorage Digital, questioned whether a broader safe harbor would make much difference in practice. He stated that issuers are choosing federal oversight because they risk having to switch regulators if their stablecoins exceed $10 billion in circulation, although exemptions are available under the law.
The GENIUS Act, signed into law in July 2025, was designed to regulate stablecoins and their issuers while preserving the role of state banking agencies. Treasury Secretary Bessent has previously likened the act to Lincoln-era banking reform, highlighting its significance in modernizing the financial infrastructure. However, the ongoing debate over implementation rules underscores the tension between federal standardization and state-level regulatory innovation in the digital asset sector.